Sierra Club Home Page

Sierra Club
Redwood Chapter Newsletter
Back to Articles Menu
  EXPLORE, ENJOY AND PROTECT THE PLANET
 
June/July 2005  

Napa Group Report

Genji Schmeder

Thollander Dinner a great success

About 130 diners enjoyed an evening of fine food and wines at the Yountville community hall on April 23. This was our fifth annual Earl Thollander award dinner, named for the late Napa Valley artist and author of "Back Roads of California". Our honoree this year, Mike Rippey, spoke about his vision for open space recreation and protection from Napa County to the Carquinez Strait. Mike was an energetic leader of the first attempt to create a Napa County open space district in 1992. We look forward to working with him to realize this vision.

The annual dinner is also our major fundraiser. This year's net proceeds of more than $5000 will be dedicated to publication of our newsletter, preservation of Clair Tapaan Lodge in the Sierra Nevada, education and outreach efforts, and advocacy for redevelopment at Lake Berryessa. Exact distribution will be decided at our June 7 ExCom meeting.

Land Stewards attack county land use authority

The Sierra Club opposes the so-called "Fair Pay For Public Benefit" initiative being circulated by the Napa Valley Land Stewards Alliance. If approved by the voters, the initiative would freeze county zoning and stifle the current update of the county general plan by the threat of litigation or compensation for any new restrictions on land use. Proposals for restoring the Napa River and its tributaries would be overshadowed by fear of legal and financial exposure.

The initiative is profoundly unfair to the residents of Napa County, who are being asked to pay landowners to protect the environment. Oregon Measure 37 was passed by the voters last November and applies retroactively to require compensation or waiver for land use restrictions. It has thrown planning throughout that state into disarray, since every locality is faced with the stark choice of either abandoning community standards to approve private projects or paying the owners not to develop. A similar measure in Nevada County California in 2002 failed by a huge margin when the voters realized their county government would go bankrupt trying to protect the local quality of life.

Lake Berryessa

The second public comment period has concluded. Several potential concessionaires have come forward to support a new concession model that would not rely upon exclusive vacation sites. These comments must now be analyzed. The Bureau of Reclamation should make its final decision this autumn.